I like them all but agree that the ones from the new PVs look a little bit blurry (and I am torn on the new Banica one since I think she should be with Arte and Pollo < <; )
Not sure how I feel about the proposed ones; Prim and I.R. are the only ones with enough art to choose from in my opinion and Gatt's wouldn't look very visually impressive with his sketchy pastel Tamara design.
Generally speaking, I dislike the discrepency between the two logo texts but it's overall a minor complaint. Also, like Octo said, there's a lot of these that just look blurry and could be done better imo. Now onto more specific stuff:
Since this is a logo that goes on the top right corner of the wiki, the logos that are centered at the bottom look off to me; much better when we had the already skewed placement of the older logos. Galley, Allen, and Riliane out.
Two why use the SCP images of Nemesis/Margarita instead of the Muzzle PV and Gift novel stuff? I am not sold on what you brought up being a good enough logo for Nemesis. Margarita is okay.
Besides the blurry issue, Banica's propsed work here doesn't have as much to it as the older one; much better imo with Arte, Pollo, and a background.
Again, besides the blurry issue, Gumina's looks alright but I wouldn't sacrifice any of these for another one.
Same thing with Lunacy, but I do like it more than the other one, generally speaking; I think Kayo's is fine though I prefer our current one.
I think we can throw out Hellish and some of the theater inhabits to make room and keep the load times low. I don't think MotG, Irregular, the Servants, or maybe even Waiter or Gammon need a spotlight. Might even be better to try throwing them together in their own logo based on the CF image, if that'll work.
In the end, the only ones I'm okay with are Sati, Kayo, and maybe Mar Mar though I think the latter could still have a better logo from the novel cover.
Muzzle's the only one I'm crazy about. Most of them have text disappearing issues though with the bg but you referenced that alreayd. Some polish to outline the text and it'll be fine imo. I'm interesting in the H&G and Gallerian one too.
The very first one is abominably blurry as is the fourth. I don't mind 2nd or 3rd but I wouldn't want to replace any of the current ones with those. I like 5 as well but it is in much of the same boat as the others.
The one with Germaine and Lily looks like one with great potential however, I don't think the text was placed properly.
There's something about illustrations of Ichika that makes themlook "official"... I don't know why, they just look like much better logos to me. Other than her, only Yuurin, Painter Brioche, Tama, and sometimes Suzunosuke make the cut for me, it seems.
I like the updated Margarita and Nemesis ones. There's also this file if you want to have more flexibility with Margarita's novel cover image. Anyone been able to get a good one with all the inhabitants either from the CF PV or their own?
Given our attempts to keep the load times from terribly lagging, I think condensing the ones we currently use for the different theater inhabitants would be a good compromise to have them while saving space for other new logos.
I mean, replace Hellish with Nemesis and condense all the inhabitants to a single logo and that'll save us 6 spaces for new logos.
Could you try overlaying the Galley logo with a resized version of his website profile? I think that shading and coloring might fit in better imo with that bg. Might be something you want to try with the others too.
The Allen one is interesting, though having just the doll clearly seen is a nitpick of mine. All the differnet DoE ones ar interesting as well.
How many logos do people feel we should have for OSS? We currently use one for Meta, one for Eve, and one for Irina and Elluka.
Could we potentially blend the original Meta logo with the Eve holding the fruits and the alternative text placed in there? Would that work without cluttering it?
I still haven't seen anyone try making some logos with all the theater inhabitants so we aren't having each one taking a spot. And can anyone resize and overlay the website colorings onto some of these SCP images? Some of the glaring effects (ie, Riliane) also are a bit much and obscure the logo. I think doing all that might improve some of these for me.
Otherwise, we got 19 currently used and that's already pushing it a little. If those afformentioned fixes happen to the Galley, Riliane, and (optionally) the Kayo and Veno,here are the ones I like:
With the changes, I'd be more lenient to having Riliane, Kayo, Galley, and Kayo to replace their corresponding logos we currently use. Margarita's already a yes for me. Same with Meta/Eve. If we get a theater inhabitant logo to condense all the ones we currently use for each inhabitant, then I'd like I.R./Lemy to have one while Nemesis replaces Hellish.
On top of that, we'd still have 7 spaces that could be taken up with other logos so I'd then be perfectly willing to maybe think of using the FotP logo, a new Praefacio logo (anyone want to try that?), maybe keep the Cloture logo, a Gumina logo, etc.
I've tried to make a Gumillia logo in the past, but other than the one I posted above (the one with her, Michaela, Elluka and Held) I haven't been able to find any nice colored images of her. If anyone could link me to them that would be great.
Some of them look really cool, but it's a shame I think they shouldn't be used as there are more "important" ones to be used first. I'm talking about you, AB-CIR. So cool and yet... Male Irina never made a big deal to begin with.
I'm sad Germaine gets her face cut in the Avadonia's family one. I also like the one from praefatio but Ney's face is being hidden by the logo which kind of ruins it.
I'd also likke to suggest the logo get moved down and off-center a little. It's covering Gammon's face and I've already made my spiel about centering a logo on an off-centered illustration in the corner. Do that and what Pika mentioned and it would be perfect imo.
Servant of Evillious wrote: I liked it better without irregular personally. Only half the face and extremely saturated in bright white. Still got that centered thing on the text too as a result. I'd move that more over Waiter.
It's with a grid, and the grid is divided into 8.5 sections, so if I decide to only use the eight theater inhabitants I'll have to estimate it. Maybe I can put the theater in Irregular's place?
Also, as for the text, I don't really know what you're getting at, so I made two versions:
Alright then. By the way, Servy, would happen to have the file of Irregular's CP Profile on hand? You know, the one with the background and everything. I think Triu used it in the logo in the above post.
Edit: Never mind, I found it. Will post the new one in a bit.
GreekTelepath wrote: Alright then. By the way, Servy, would happen to have the file of Irregular's CP Profile on hand? You know, the one with the background and everything. I think Triu used it in the logo in the above post.
Edit: Never mind, I found it. Will post the new one in a bit.
I wasn't aware the file existed so no, I don't have it. Glad you found it.
I think it's a great idea (there are too many Capriccio Farce banners imho).
For OSS, I'd like to have banners for both L&B and H&G. The OSSCE album illust works for both.
Also, I would love a banner for MotC, since she's the most important (including her Maria connection) of the masters, so far. I think that her illust from Evils Court would be best, to replace the current one of Capriccio Farce.
I'm late but I have to say the only thing I don't really like is Banica's image. I'd rather the image not be flipped around like this, because they always look weird when you do that. I mean, I haven't seen the alternative but still 0 0
These would be in addition to the current ones right? I really like the ones we have now even though I also like these new ones, so it'd be perfect if we could just use all of them rather than limiting ourselves to just the sinners when there's so much more to Evillious than that and the sides of the wiki is already the sinners.
I'd really like variety in the banners more than anything else, with lots and lots of them if we could ^^;
I'd rather we wait until the Muzzle novel drops in case it covers the Theater; otherwise we'll be missing out on some potential illustrations.
Also, I feel that Grave and the Servants are already represented through the banners for Banica and H&G (the latter one I haven't made), while Waiter and Gear can be represented through Riliane and Adam (whom they're implied to be).
Gammon's definitely going to show his face in Muzzle, and I'd like both him and Nyoze to be in the banner. As for Ma and Court (who's implied to be Maria), I think they're important enough to have their own banners.
I think they both look quite nice ^^ I would have thought we'd use more recent art for ma, but then again it really wouldn't blend with the other theater inhabitants considering most of them just have have their capprio art to work from so it gets a pass from me
Now that I think about it, I think we should really stick to the whole minimalist thing. That being said, can anyone make transparent pictures of Ma's books (the ones that appear in Capriccio Farce) and Lemy's knife?