Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20131006042158

So two experiments have been done: One was to add onto the Featured in... section by expanding this to the books as well, which Allen has been our delightful little g.p. The other experiment was reworking the entire section as an Appearances section with a scrollable list of appearances with subtexts to specify their appearances, which has included everything including albums and non-canon works. Elluka was our applicant for this wonderful Project Fi.

The question to the users here is, which do you think works better with the overall page? I personally prefer the latter. While I like the pretty galleries, I find they aren't working with books and doesn't solve the multiple problems we have had with character appearances whether being mentioned by name only or being in a non-canon work counts. I feel the Elluka example solves all this and more.

Also, because this section was renamed "Appearances" in this example, I'd like the actual Appearance sub-section in Character Traits to be removed. I honestly think it's kind of redundant considering we already have the galleries to show you what characters look like. This gets even more redundant when so many characters have the same or similar appearances. I think descriptions should be kept to minor characters.

Thoughts? 