Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-12376798-20140815224619/@comment-24205135-20140816003024

I agree with Nemesis being Gumillia, especially after the new profiles were released. However, I disagree about MA being Elluka. It seems the song suggests Nemesis knew MA as "Kayo Sudou", so I think Nemesis' memories were tampered with.

Servy has released the profiles from the characters from the Gift novel. It's here: http://theevilliouschronicles.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Servant_of_Evillious/Gift_Website_Profiles

As you can see, we have a "Hanne Lore" that smiles just like Elluka and "is older than she looks", and "Heidemarie Lorre", her "sister". Interestingly, she seems to have developed a violent temper. We don't see much of a violent temper in Gumillia in the "Story of Evil", so what could have made her develop it?

I believe something really terrible happened to her during the Enbizaka war, but I don't know what it is. In any case, it started to make her unstable, which is probably a big piece of the puzzle of why we have the Nemesis of today.

Another big question: is MA Elluka? Irina? Kayo? A combination of Irina + Elluka? Irina + Kayo? Elluka + Kayo?

Interestingly, the Sloth PV clearly says we have "Julia" as Margarita's friend, and the novel says we have "Elluka" is her friend. I think this contradiction is intentional, and, although I can't prove this at all, I believe the movies MA talks about are the movies we see, which would be biased to favor her.

Now, is there a third person in the story right now? Is Kayo older than the movies suggest, and has she been working behind the scenes since after the Enbizaka war?