Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6986530-20170327230407/@comment-67.66.94.66-20170413081452

190.232.90.32 wrote: 67.66.94.66 wrote: However, as of right now, there is no evidence that isn't circumstantial. This is exactly the pitfall we fell into with Irregular and assuming he was Allen--and then he turned out not to be. Despite mountains of circumstantial evidence. Well, Irregular wasn't so circumstantial. Allen was directly called Irregular (and it's still possible that Allen and Irregular share some connection). That was done directly to deceive us.

It's possible that Waiter isn't Rilliane (in the same way, it's possible that Gear isn't Adam). Mothy can make all theses connections to deceive us.

However, that doesn't change that, so far, the indications point towards some connection between Rilliane and Waiter. I doubt it was done ~to deceive us~. I think you're attributing things that aren't there.

Gear is directly called "Soul of Adam" and we literally have Adam in the spoon, occupying the space the demon is absent from (and given what we have in the Nemesis novel, he likely was gone well before Gallerian had the spoon). So unless he's Kyle, there's not really any other reason for him to not be Adam whereas we never had any reason to believe Irregular was Allen. Especially since "irregular" just means "abnormal" and I really doubt there was ever going to be a single thing ever referred to as "Irregular."

Waiter has no direct connection to Riliane right now. The only evidence is: they're both waiting for someone and they're both Rins connected to Pride (and Waiter is said to be the personification of the mirror in the Capriccio Farce PV text). If Waiter is anyone, I feel, she's more likely to be Marie at this point, just up and walking around far sooner than MotG (who is Banica, who became the demon after she ate Vlad). Hell, the only thing that says she's waiting for someone is a few lines in Heartbeat Clocktower that talk more about her counterpart being gone, which everyone assumed meant she had a Len somewhere. For all we know, at this point, it's one of the other demons.

As of right now, Irregular and Allen share no real connection besides both being called a term WE erroneously assumed could only ever refer to one person despite nothing saying that. Irregular was always displayed as trapped, while Allen was always shown as out and about at points after his death and interacting with people in some way--so how the wikia kept assuming Irregular = Allen is beyond me. I feel that's a case of "lost in translation" just like how we were shocked by Ma and Gallerian having an affair, despite being told as much well before the Muzzle song.