Talk:Mariam Phutapie/@comment-174.49.245.221-20170325005438/@comment-7342272-20170325214744

I'm not sure descendants of sinners (which make them like pseudo/semi-HERs?) count as "natural HERs", which Prim is noted to be, by Irina, who probably knows all to well about HER. I highly doubt Prim descends from Venomania and Priema Soap.

There's a bit more leeway in Mariam's case since Mariam is Asmodean/born to a family in Asmodean, but I still doubt she's from Venomania and Mirigan Adi.

Also should be noted that maybe he had children with unidentified women in the harem that went on to do... nothing. Mothy could just be focusing on the ones that actually do something in the main story/have children of their own who did something relating to the main story.

Also, every other HER we've seen is either a Ghoul Child with built-in HER, descendants of Ghoul Children, reincarnations of HERs, descendants of HERs/sinners, or sinners themselves. I think Prim is supposed to be an example of a natural HER. Not spurred on by the influence of sin, Irina, or relations to another HER, just the natural working of genetics. The page on HER says if one or both parents have HER, the chances of offspring having it increase dramatically. This implies the chances of two non-HER parents having a HER child is extremely low, but not impossible. Makes sense for two non-Venomania-related characters to exist out of all the other HERs in this series.