Talk:Clockwork Lullaby (song)/@comment-94.14.6.139-20180824054446

Put my thoughts on the forum, but will put here too in better aspect: the one who thinks the unknown singer is just Clockwork Lullaby/Music box itself. I am aware people have tried to identify her as a "character". However if you were to decide to set her as "a matter of form", majority of what is linked to them actually makes better sense when thought thoroughly.

There is no EC point in time because CL is everywhere in the story. The greedy hearted one would be deemed as not a single entity, but rather in all levels of those who come into contact with it (and there is a few of them). In order for a music box to sing, you must give it gears/words. In order to create something out of the music box, you must experiment with with changing it (and LuLiLa has seen its mix of changes). Who is giving them the gears/words? Ones who decided to make music boxes or want to harness Clockwork Lullaby magic (I would put Kiril for that personally, however I'm betting he's not the only one / original maker).

And lastly, this idea has been thrown at us twice now, even the quote above can practically be a solid answer as "This singing voice is the clockwork lullaby." and the new version "In the end, I of the miniature garden, Wasn’t anyone". The clockwork lullaby cannot learn words for emotion, which are the words it questions to find (Playing with Words), because she is in object form. I do not find it unusual that a song would be about an aspect rather than a character. So unless there's input from the CL Album booklet relating to them, this is about as logical as its going to get.