Talk:Re birthday (song)/@comment-16456175-20130920063956

You know, the premise for the song actually makes a lot of sense.

Allen, unlike Rillane, never came to regret his actions. He died beliving that his sister was a good person and generally being evil (but of course, doing it for love and loyalty). Because of this, his soul is still tainted by sin (ironic that he is usually represented as the good half even though Rillane repents and he doesn't).

For whatever reason, MotC sees his tainted soul as a terrible thing, most likely due to her strong sense of justice or something...

Anyways, after Allen is "purified" by being trapped until he repents and realizes his wrongs he is roborn. He ends up being the only good person in the theatre, causing him to become the good half of the Waiter/Irregular duo and becomes the Master of the Heavenly Yard.