Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-189.171.21.68-20150317012416/@comment-6192846-20150317183122

Neat theory, but not sure I buy it.

1) SCP confirms Eve and Ma are separate entities existing independently of one another; any "corruption" by Eve would imply a lot more than just the witch sitting in her body.

2) SCP confirms Eve is alive and unchanged since her Gift appearance. Eve is a mad witch acting on instinct without any purpose; Ma is portrayed as a motivated schemer. Eve hasn't been once portrayed with the capacity to manipulate at that level. She just hypnotizes people in ignorance.

3) Elluka's "corruption" wouldn't explain the evasion about Gumillia seeing Margarita and (potentially) hypnotizing her so she wouldn't remember that.

4) Elluka's "corruption" wouldn't explain her attitude toward Lemy as Eve clearly despises her foster children and wants nothing to do with them, if not just outright kill them.

5) Eve's a Miku, not a GUMI; to have Miku + KAITO = GUMI without a GUMI somewhere prior in that bloodline makes no sense in Evillious' world logic.

6) Recreating events equals hearing voices? That makes less sense than the above.

It's got some good points, but I think this theory is trying too hard to cover all the bases with what little info we had. You'd have an easier time convincing me if you focused on solely the 609-611 period imo.