Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-189.202.235.234-20150317182438/@comment-96.234.151.66-20151202215500

I like this theory. It ties in well with the first Punishment destroying the forest that Irrefular is born in as he's born, though if this is true, it might be considered odd that they weren't born as twins.

My main point of contention for this, however, is that it doesn't explain all of the other Punishments that Nemesis uses to destroy Evillious.

Perhaps the very first Punishment was Irregular's reincarnated twin, but I'm not sure. Personally, I believe that Irregular is the reincarnation of Maria Moonlit's firstborn son that was thrown into a river. I suggest this because Maria's soul is likely what inhabits the Clockworker Doll (I understand that it isn't confimred canon, it's just my guess) and it would be the second time "she" had birthed a child as a virgin mother.

Still, I very much like your theory, and think that it's wholly possible.