Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20140612134000/@comment-67.83.114.176-20140904223400

Honestly, I personally don't care if the pages are kept separate or merged as long as the issue isn't danced around the same way the "Is Allen Irregular?" thing was for the past few years prior to the release of Heavenly Yard. It's just a pet peeve of mine, but as long as it's not treated as though we need a carefully worded statement spoken in Red Truth or something to accept it as fact I'm fine.

However, from what I'm seeing, the best path would be to keep the Nemesis and MOTHellishY pages separate. Not because there's not enough evidence that Nemesis is Hellish - believe me, there IS evidence, in fact it's practically being rubbed in our faces the same way the whole Allen/Irregular thing was - but be cause we simply don't know when Nemesis stopped being Nemesis and started being Hellish, and what, exactly, caused it in the first place.

As long as we don't know exactly how Nemesis became Hellish, there's room for doubt, no matter how obvious it is. I view the Allen/Irregular, and Elluka/MA page seperation similarly - we don't know what happened to cause Allen to become Irregular, or when it happened, and we know absolutely NOTHING about whatever the heck turned Elluka into MA, so until we get a straight answer as to HOW their identities changed, they should have separate pages.

Once we learn how Nemesis turned into Hellish, then there should be no problem with merging their pages together if the situation calls for it. Same for Allen and Irregular since I brought them up - we know nothing about what happened to Allen between the end of Heavenly Yard and his reappearance as Irregular in the EC 990s, so there's always a chance for some form of shenanigans like "EVERYONE IS EVE".

TL;DR I say you guys should keep the pages separate, not because we don't know if Nemesis is Hellish for certain, but because we don't know how Nemesis BECAME Hellish. They might be separate identities, they might not, we don't know, so until that gap of knowledge is filled they should be kept as separate articles.