Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-66.169.45.26-20140617040733/@comment-6192846-20140617193034

It's always possible for a character to be a HER, the chance is just extraordinarily low for anyone whose parent(s) aren't already HERs.

Imo, Prim isn't a HER, just a little whacky. Even if she was, it doesn't really matter. Her being one wouldn't serve any purpose in the plot, at least no more than her just being a petty, arrogant *****. I find Prim's character believable as is so I don't see why mothy would make her a HER on top of that.

---

I like the Irina theory but imo, there'd have to be a good reason.

All our characters in the songs have been possessed by the demons, and (at least so far), neither Elluka nor Irina have been affected by the vessels (the latter implying those who have strong magical power can easily use the tools without needing to be possessed).

Imo, our Gumi character has two options:

1) She's Gumillia

2) She's somehow related to Gumina

In either circumstance, Irina could be using their body (assuming she is alive and/or in need of a host during the song's period) as her own. But that goes back to my point on why.

Why would Irina be possessed by the Demon of Wrath and doing [insert major Evillious event here] when her sole focus has been simply to collect the vessels (and eventually come in contact with Elluka for currently unknown reasons)?

If it was unintentional. Why was she in this possession where she would be possessed? Why was she so happening to use a Gumi character's body during this period?

All in all, the concept would need a fair explanation.