Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20150223174230/@comment-25932613-20150313220330

Well the same argument could be made about Lemy too. Riliane didn't have kids so how does Lemy exist? We know that Ney is going to be in the novel so there is already a connection to Gretel in the novel. Rin Chan was at least in my opinion the one who was destined to be the Gretel of that time but because Ney is in the Glass Rin Chan only took on Gretel's appearance but nothing else. Like how Allen and Riliane did even though they weren't the actual reincarnations.