Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20150223174230/@comment-67.65.248.45-20150319133415

...Uh. Just because she's not Gretel doesn't mean she's Riliane. In fact, if they mention incarnation along with Gretel, they're probably saying that she's NOT Gretel. :/

I get you really want to be right, but I say A. wait for it and B. you're probably wrong and looking for confirmation where there necessarily isn't any.

The fact they mentioned Rindo makes me think it's more likely Rin Chan and Riliane are descended from Rindo rather than Rin Chan being Riliane. Especially when Allen said the only ones who reincarnated were Gretel and Hansel aside from his one-time thing, and even then, Allen is SPECIAL.