Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-96.241.215.64-20141202195029

This has been discussed before, but I believe I can actually back up the claim that this has a good deal of truth as a theory.

1. My first point, Its spelt 'HER Whisper', but I think that is more a red herring to point out that it isn't [her] the syndrome or illness. Because mothy doesn't ever spell it as anything but a lower case [her], the fandom and wiki spell it HER, not mothy. And the only time it appears capatitalised is during MoN, and that is more due to the stencil font not allowing lowercase.

2. [her] has never been stated as causing voices in the people with it, Irina, who is the longest lived [her] never states hearing voices and neither does any other [her] we know. Any voices involved with the head always seem to be involving spirits or demons of sin, and those have requirements outside of having [her].

3. LeviaBehemo's voices aren't known to most anyone outside Sickle and Held, so we don't know how they sound. Their powers are also not really discussed, its just implied they are capable of great damage to the world. But the possibility of imitating someone's voice is within the realm of believability, I mean the Demons of Sin seem capable of it and more, why not Gods?

4. Sickle never says anything about giving favors to Elluka, Elluka dying and then speaking to Kiril would require Sickle's assistance as that is the only way Allen has returned to Evillious. But Sickle only ever gave Allen that favor, so its not possible Elluka was ever given such a favor. And therefore never could return from the Heavenly Yard to tell Kiril to do anything, as well she shows no motive to wanting to be revived. (This is outside being revived, of course.)

5. LeviaBehemo are the only one's that benefitted from what Kiril did, and it doesn't seem like they planned for their body to fall apart when it did.

Another thing is, you can look at the Whispers as more a progressively changing perception of the voice. Like HER Whisper, being perceived as Kiril thinking he is going mad and hearing his dead fiancee's voice, which is a normal way to think of hearing a recently dead loved one's voice in your head.

Her Whisper, being perceived more as being genuinely Elluka's voice from the afterlife, since it seems to imply by the next set that Kiril is following the voice's orders.

??? Whisper, both implied by the label and the way the voice seems to be distorted, kinda imply that Kiril does not at all recognize this voice, and that it is the exact same voice ordering him as before. Which the lyrics imply, whoever was saying that was hurrying Kiril, and frustrated at his speed of using the ark.

So, if someone was imitating a voice and got mad or frustrated the possibility of hurrying Kiril and those emotions might make someone slip up and stop imitating the voice all together.

I'd also like to note Kiril is a powerful magician, and its stated that is all that is needed for spirits such as Held and his forest spirits to be able to speak to someone.

If anything comes out to contradict something in this or disputes the reasons in this, then oh well. 