Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20150419144803/@comment-6192846-20150624123729

Saying "He never implied _____ when you think he would" isn't good reasoning imo. His narration literally drops story details inconsistently without explanation. "You'd think" he'd explain Ma given how many times she's referenced, but nope.

Same here. Allen literally only tells us that he incarnated on the ground and lived in Jakoku as a human again for a time. Nothing else. No mention if he got mind wiped per Third Period's rules, that he apparently killed Kayo with Grim the End, and especially not the why and how he ended up accomplishing this reincarnation.

It's definitely not too hard to swallow with everything else SCP expects you to (read SCP without having read any of the other light novels).

Riliane being Rin's logistic issue does seem to be a problem. If Riliane's reincarnating normally, why not Allen? The easiest answer would be Sickle somehow got him out of a reincarnation cycle or his status as Irregular makes him not reincarnate normally. On the other end, H&G are the only two who have apparently been continually reincarnating. If Behemo is telling the truth, then there might be other, unknown circumstances.