Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20140612134000/@comment-24526600-20140915033507

Seven Heavenly Virtues wrote: Sure, Conchita. But we can't possibly know the whole truth. Not even Mothy does, as he's still writing the story. If he wants, he can change things on a whim.

We can't know the whole truth, but there's no reason to post assumptions instead of waiting for a confirmation,who's desperate for (potentially) false information?

Considering we don't know the absolute truth, we can take the most reasonable assumption, and so far, the most reasonable assumption is that Nemesis is Master of Hellish Yard. We have the Muzzle of Nemesis' PV, we have a screen shot of the album, we have the Master of Hellish Yard song, and we have the crossfade.

We can but the question is if we should. Just as you said, users should be able to reach conclusions on their own. If they think that Nemesis=Hellish then that's alright, but if we as a wikia say that Nemesis=Hellish then users are going to think that Nemesis is 100% Hellish.

If we are wrong, we could even add to the Wiki, "when the Muzzle of Nemesis album was released, we thought Master of Hellish Yard and Nemesis were the same given these facts, but now that Mothy has said / has released X, that has been proven wrong". I think that's far more honest, and this even documents the line of reasoning of the fans and Wiki users.

The thing is, we don't want to risk being wrong. If it was something like the Eve and Margarita case, then that was inevitable and there was nothing we really could've done about it. We can prevent misleading information plus, I don't think that being honest in that fashion is very professional.