Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20150304021219/@comment-67.66.94.92-20150406173713

Seven Heavenly Virtues wrote: Octofan wrote: I am going to say that at this point, given this evidence, I think Re_Birthday is pretty much Irregular's song.

There are far, far more details in the song that point to Irregular than Allen (if any point to Allen at all except that one illustration of debatable accuracy and the word "message," which only implicates Regret Message) and now we have information from the Pierrot novel that can explain his supposed loss of an ego even outside of his ego being artistic liberty in the song. (A person's prior memories being sealed after [reincarnation].)

However, I'd say make a minor character section and remove the info from Irregular (but perhaps make it clear in trivia that the song is pointing to Irregular) if it's the majority's vote. Octo, from what we get, though, Irregular (Court) wasn't even born. Plus, there are also elements in the song that are linked to Allen.

From what I see, Re_birthday has achieved a dead end similar to "Kept waiting for a response". It doesn't seem to fit the canon considering what we have now. ...Except that SCaP explicitly says that Irregular was born JUST prior to the world exploding, IIRC. It fits canon so far, and Mothy hasn't said it's NOT canon like he did for Kept Waiting.

Just because things seem to link to Allen doesn't mean they actually do. See: TLR and Gumillia.