Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20140612134000/@comment-67.66.94.125-20140917205334

It's possible he dropped the doll at some point in there, but otherwise, the only other explanation is he was presented the exact same deal twice.

Also, we never really see his outright reaction on MoN with the line about "never to the likes of you." It's possible he embraced her off-screen and she simply pushed him back and then placed the gun to his forehead--meaning he closed the distance between them instead of her (as she was previously across the room).