Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6986530-20170327230407/@comment-26174543-20171116171531

as I said earlier, we have yet to see her in a novel post awakening when she wasn't already dead. all of the sinners in scap (besides nemesis of course) had already passed away, and we never actually saw her in the greed or wrath novels. that'd be like saying that kokutan can't be a reincarnation because allen is clearly aware that he's himself in the scap novel.

but even so, besides the fact that arte and pollo were fully aware of their past and clearly still count as reincartions, the awakened vessels are just that, the personifications of the souls that were in the vessels. it's at the very least set up to make it clear that it differs from traditional reincarnation, but we have no idea what the process entails yet so making assumptions about it is pretty much pointless right now.

and again, I'm not suggesting that we won't ever merge the pages, just that we should wait until the situation is clarified before we do