Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20141209211951/@comment-6192846-20150221210011

Impossible.

Mikulia was already pregnant with child and had to give birth to that child before she died and have Elluka witness it. Elluka would've already been tipped off that something was wrong if she saw Mikulia die then heard she fled from Abito and ended up at a brothel and met her there.

The only reason Elluka didn't think anything was wrong with Platonic being Mikulia's descendant was because she assumed the only child Mikulia had was where the thief came from. When she heard about the tales of Flower of the Plateau from Mayor Julia, it set off her alarms because that only child was allegedly killed and the portrait of the countess was definitely "Mikulia".

The recent Lunacy tree supports that the child she had with Veno was a boy and if she had more than one kid, Elluka's entire deduction in Gift makes no sense. If the child in the FotP and the Veno kid are the same, there are no contradictions in any source material.