Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6986530-20170327230407/@comment-67.66.94.66-20170415120240

My deal is that I am seeing people clinging to this with zero proof besides the same things that led to them saying that Irregular was Allen. And yes, it is random guessing RE: Postman. She was a pre-existing person, and given that Ma was interested in Michelle, too, I doubt that she decided to change the appearance of a pre-existing person just to drop a soul in her when we see no indication of that for Michelle for Irina.

Banica was always Banica, but even as early as SoE we have images in canon of her dressed as Grave. And just because Banica at one point possessed Riliane means nothing when she literally only did so thinking she was Gretel. Banica then gave kind of zero fucks outside of having a vessel, and it seemed more that Eater and Lich were the ones attached to Waiter because when Banica found something she was interested in, Waiter was abandoned to serve out a sentence in their place.

I'm not denying a relationship. I never did. I just do not, at all, believe Waiter IS Riliane and think this is another case of people not being able to let go of the character--which is a common thing in this fandom, it feels, when it comes to Riliane and Allen especially. Her story is over for the most part. She's had two conclusions, and the entire Riliane thing barely played a part in Rin Miroku and felt more afterthought to please fans. But then, I never read her actions in SCaP as being her reverting and her being playful from context (I really can't see the prissy, prideful Riliane getting messy in a cake like that), and that's why she got so upset and ran off--Germaine taking things too far.

By your own logic applied here, though, Banica isn't ACTUALLY the Demon of Gluttony, just a person who replaced the demon but still a person and human (despite being referred to as a demon). Adam is already a weird spot, and again the only one in the spoon to begin with at that point. As for Eve, there was no reason for her to revert to Margarita narratively aside from it being a showcase of the Sinners. She could have easily reverted to her original form, since she clearly remembered it, and Eve does remember all of her incarnations as shown in Gift, so no, I don't buy that.