Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-6192846-20130913170916/@comment-6192846-20141027123231

89.156.125.31 wrote: Snip. Ah, so we're moving this out of the Gift thread and into this on, eh? I can live with that. I was going to bring it up soon anyhow, since Platonic's section was added to the Clockworker's Doll article.

From my perspective, there had to be two Calgaround daughters. Regardless of when, the fact Earl Calgaround believes he has a daughter and that said daughter ran away solidifies that a girl like Platonic existed at one point. Eve's other two transmigrations are based on actual people (though one was basically a blank template).

It's possible something similar to Margarita occurred and Irina set up the Doll to replace the actual Calgaround daughter (for whatever reason that still isn't explained). It's also possible when AB-CIR allegedly "tested" Platonic as a potential vessel, he killed the child and replaced her with the Doll as a more useful pawn (she is the one that's supposed to be carrying the thing after all).

But, there's also the fact Platonic returns to her old life, meaning her "father" had to have met her again. If AB-CIR swapped out the real thing with the Doll, then that would imply that Platonic already looked like Mikulia, which is odd. The Phantom Thief is definitely the Doll as Eve even comments with "nostalgia" for the events.

This is something that seems near impossible to safely assume in any way, imo.

GreekTelepath wrote: Snip. None. Like you indicated, the conversation died. XD