Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-5758590-20130102201828/@comment-6192846-20130130215516

In my opinion, MA has Elluka's personality but a little bit more to the extreme. If Irina is involved in any way, it is not as obvious as it could be. While we have yet to receive a proper explanation as to why, I think Elluka has been simply lying.

I mean, while Irina's plan is not known to us and most of her actions seem "scattered," Elluka has not shown any realy change in her course either. She's the only one who has actually been mentioned as having this idea of a "utopia" being formed from the combination of all the sins and she was the first and only person to tell Gallerian that bringing the sins together was for granting the holder their wish.

She could easily lie about these things to help move her plan along of gathering and sealing all the sins and has simply decided that Gallerian and, later, the awakened vessels would do it all for her.

Before Marigold Plateau, Elluka was already acting pretty extreme, such as when she killed Lemy. I think that Elluka is pretty heartless compared to her Story of Evil only because she doesn't know anyone besides Gumillia hundreds of years from then and has no reason to want to keep them alive.

MA is obviously a manipulator and Irina has been nowhere to be found but I am not convinced about the two sharing a body or Irina posessing Elluka again.