Board Thread:Theories Discussion/@comment-5758590-20130102201828/@comment-5758590-20130119203745

For delayed speaking, I'm sorry.

It is both women in the same body, therefoe they share techniques. Elluka and Irina are able to 'fight' for control whenever needed. However, it may also be that they merge into one 'spirit' later on(hense the purple eyes that MA have). I do not believe Gammon is Elluka, however it is a very good theory. When time is at hand, I will look more into it. The fact remains that Gammon nearly did get eaten by MotGY, but he was 'saved' by Waiter.

As for your second theory... This one is more plausable, at least in one part. For Elluka to become that, as she shows 'skadefryd'(I'm not sure what the proper word is in English), it seems to be a trait only Irina possesses, as Elluka is shown to be caring to friends. After 611, the general tone of the sins are far less gruesome than before, but they're still there. Irina wants to start them and Elluka wants to stop them... Writing much, I do not mind, as it is fun to reply!

EvilliousFoodEater, I do not understand your theory well. What do you mean?

As for the latest comment, it is also a good indication of it being Irina if we go by only songs. The novels, I am afraid, will speak against us because Irina appeared in DoEI: WG(2011) when Capriccio Farce arrived in 2012. Therefore, she would have already had a 'debut'.

Any debut from first person of Elluka, unless I am looking incorrectly, I do not see any. This could also swing both ways as the 'Sorceress of Time'(Being whoever she is) finally being allowed to sing for herself. Please correct me if I am wrong, but the other two songs in which she canonically appears are Chrono Story('Sneered the Sorceress') and Recollective Music Box('The Fiancé and Sister)! These are spoken from the view of an unknown person(Though it is really Gammon Octo, who wrote the songs in his time at the theatre) looking at their episodes.